Dallas Gerstle Snelson, LLP Austin

Copyright sign

Copyrights for Schematic Drawings

What is the impact of granting a license to a property owner to use a set a schematic drawings?  The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit recently answered this question in Loeb-Defever v. Mako, LLC. In Mako, Pauda Realty requested Loeb Architects, LLC to prepare a design for an assisted living facility in Conroe, Texas.  Pauda and Loeb subsequently entered into two separate service contracts each of which contained a limitation that schematics could not be used on other projects except by agreement in writing and with subsequent compensation to Loeb. After Loeb partially com
Women electrical engineer working

ERCOT and Sovereign Immunity

Does the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) liability for the catastrophic effects of Winter Storm Uri in 2021? More than two years after the storm, the Texas Supreme Court has answered the question, no. On June 23, 2023, the Texas Supreme Court in a divided 5-4 opinion held that ERCOT is entitled to sovereign immunity, concluding that ERCOT is an “arm of the state” because it is under the complete purview of the Texas Public Utility Commission (PUC), the Legislature, and the statutory requirements of the Public Utility Regulatory Act (PURA). The two cases the Court conside
Chatbot text on futuristic artificial neural network

ChatGPT Sanctions

In the age of artificial intelligence and expanding technology, the advancements are endless, but does AI have the capacity to practice law? The apparent answer is no, at least not without exhaustive checking by an attorney. On June 22, 2023, a Federal District Judge in New York sanctioned two attorneys and their law firm, jointly, because one attorney, who was not licensed to practice law in the New York Federal Court, relied on responses from ChatGPT with made-up case law and citations in preparing his response to a motion to dismiss, and the other attorney, who was licensed to practice in t
High angle view of courtroom

Racial Bias Nullifies $9.6 Million Verdict

What is the consequence of an attorney selecting jurors on the basis of race?  The Texas Supreme Court recently overturned a $9.6 million verdict from a Dallas County jury, finding that race was used as the basis for selecting jurors and excluding potential ones. The facts in United Rental North America, Inc. v. Evans are tragic. In March 2015, United Rentals decided to move two pieces of equipment from its San Antonio to its Irving locations.  One was a forklift with a boom arm measuring slightly over 8 feet tall, and the other was a boom lift measuring 10 feet tall. Due predominantly to la
Arbitration agreement and gavel on a desk.

Eyeing Arbitration

The Corpus Christi Court of Appeals recently held that a family’s allegations against a funeral home for its handling of a relative’s body were subject to arbitration, even though some of the family members were not parties to the agreement to arbitrate. After her mother passed away, Anabel Gonzalez entered into a contract with SCI Funeral Services, LLC d/b/a Funeraria del Angel (SCI) for visitation and embalmment services. The contract contained a mandatory arbitration provision. According to Anabel and her family members, her mother’s eye and mouth opened, leaking fluid, during a visit